Keshav Shree’s Where Are You Really From? is a sharp, engaging, and refreshingly original comedy that dives deep into the complexities of cultural identity, assimilation, and the unspoken weight of accents in defining who we are. With an inventive premise—a successful Indian managing director in London suddenly losing his British accent after a stroke—the film balances humor and introspection, making for a compelling watch.
Shree, who also wrote and directed the film, proves himself to be a multi-talented force. His performance as Hari Prasad Tiwari is particularly striking, delivering one of the most convincing portrayals of a stroke I’ve seen on screen. The way he effortlessly shifts between accents is impressive, showcasing not only technical skill but also the emotional turmoil his character experiences as he struggles to reclaim his place in a world that now seems uncertain. The supporting cast, including MJ Lee as Cristina, Ruchika Jain as Shweta Tiwari, and Tim Heath as Professor, all deliver strong performances, each adding depth to Hari’s journey.
Visually, Where Are You Really From? employs an interesting mix of wide angles and documentary-like realism, allowing the audience to sit with both the comedy and discomfort of each scene. Shree and his cinematographer make great use of lighting, playing with tone and atmosphere in ways that subtly reinforce Hari’s internal conflict. This, combined with a sharp script that never over-explains its themes, ensures the film remains both entertaining and thought-provoking.
Beyond its humor, the film poses deeper questions about the immigrant experience and how identity can be both lost and rediscovered in unexpected ways. It never offers easy answers, instead letting the audience grapple with the same uncertainties Hari faces. The thematic weight of the film is handled with nuance, ensuring that even its most absurd moments remain grounded in reality.
If there’s one element that left me slightly puzzled, it’s the final scene in the elevator. It’s ambiguous—perhaps intentionally so—but I wasn’t sure if it was meant to suggest déjà vu, an alternate perspective, or something else entirely. Still, that small moment of uncertainty doesn’t detract from the film’s overall impact.
Where Are You Really From? is a clever, well-crafted film that cements Keshav Shree as a talent both in front of and behind the camera. With its blend of sharp humor, insightful commentary, and strong performances, it’s a film that makes you think and just might provoke an interesting conversation on the car ride home.
Jessie Hobson