Director Andrew Callaghan opens Dear Kelly by challenging Maslow's hierarchy of needs, proposing that humans only require three essentials: security, significance, and connection. This unconventional theory sets the stage for a profound exploration of what happens when these needs are stripped away.
Dear Kelly delves into the life of Kelly Johnson, also known as "Kelly J. Patriot," a figure familiar to fans of Callaghan's All Gas No Brakes and Channel 5. Kelly's extreme right-wing views and erratic behavior initially paint him as a typical alt-right conspiracy theorist. However, a passionate rant about a man named Bill Joiner, who Kelly claims stole his home, intrigues Callaghan and launches a four-year journey into Kelly's life.
The documentary reveals Kelly as a deeply flawed individual who finds his sense of security, significance, and connection within the alt-right, to the distress of his family. Callaghan's empathetic approach sheds light on the factors driving Kelly to political extremism, highlighting his struggles with substance abuse, narcissistic personality disorder, and a desperate need to feel important. The film portrays Kelly as a tragic figure whose actions stem from fear of losing his dreams.
Callaghan's storytelling in Dear Kelly is more mature than his previous work, This Place Rules. He maintains a journalistic integrity, allowing viewers to form their own opinions about Kelly. The film navigates the complexities of Kelly's mental health issues and substance abuse with sensitivity, and Callaghan's treatment of Bill Joiner's role in the story is notably respectful.
Though still a work in progress, Dear Kelly is an impressive documentary. The editing, while needing some refinement, effectively weaves together a vast collection of footage, keeping the audience engaged from start to finish. Despite some reliance on stock b-roll and occasional narrative derailments, the film's heart and humanity shine through.
Andrew Callaghan has created a compelling and thought-provoking documentary that challenges viewers to understand and empathize with those drawn to political extremism. Dear Kelly is a testament to Callaghan's unique ability to humanize even the most controversial figures, making it a must-see for anyone interested in the personal stories behind the political headlines.
If you have the chance to attend a screening, don't miss it. Dear Kelly is an unforgettable journey into the human condition, reminding us that our neighbors and friends, no matter how flawed, are worthy of understanding and compassion.
Jessie Hobson